The conversation should have ended thirty seconds ago. You answered the coach’s question. You explained the ruling. You listened to his response. You may even have acknowledged that you understand why he sees the play differently. There is nothing more that needs to be said.
But the coach still looks angry. Worse, you can tell that he thinks you are wrong. So you add one more sentence. The coach responds. You clarify. He pushes back. You explain again, this time with a little more detail. Now you are not simply discussing the ruling. You are explaining why you made the ruling, what you saw, where you were positioned, and perhaps even what another official saw. You may remind the coach that you have been doing this for a long time or that you know the rule.
At some point, something important has changed. You are no longer trying to communicate information.
You are trying to manage the coach’s perception of you.
That is a very human impulse. Most of us want to be respected, and officials are no different. We want coaches to see us as competent, reasonable, approachable, and professional. We want them to believe that we know the rules, understand the game, and care about getting plays right. Many officials, whether they would admit it or not, carry an image of the official they hope coaches see when they look at them. We want to be the official coaches trust. We want to be the official they are happy to see walk onto the field on Friday night.
There is nothing wrong with wanting to earn respect. The problem begins when we start communicating to control whether we are respected.
A difficult conversation with a coach can threaten the image we want to maintain. The coach does not accept our explanation. He questions our judgment. He thinks we missed the play. Maybe he thinks we do not know the rule. Suddenly, the conversation feels unresolved—not because the coach needs more information, but because we do not like the way he is now interpreting us.
So we stay. We explain again because we want him to understand. We add context because we want him to know we had a good reason. We defend our decision because we do not want him to think we are incompetent. We get the last word because we cannot tolerate walking away while someone still believes we are wrong.
The conversation may look like it is still about football, but it is no longer about football. It is about us.
The purpose of communication is to communicate clearly, concisely, and correctly. The purpose is not to control what the other person thinks of you when the conversation is over.
That distinction is difficult because good communication does not guarantee a desirable outcome. You can give a completely accurate explanation and the coach may still think you do not know the rule. You can listen patiently, and the coach may still think you are arrogant. You can enforce a necessary boundary professionally, and the coach may still believe you have a bad attitude. You can end the conversation at exactly the right moment, and the coach may interpret your departure as dismissive.
You have to be willing to let him.
That does not mean we stop caring about how we communicate. In fact, it means the opposite. We should care deeply about what’s actually within our control. Were my words accurate? Was my explanation clear? Did I listen? Was my tone professional? Did I answer the question that was asked? Did I avoid sarcasm, defensiveness, and unnecessary confrontation? Did I know when the conversation was no longer productive?
Those are our responsibilities. The coach’s final opinion of us is not.
This is where some officials struggle with the idea of being a great communicator. They believe a successful conversation ends with the coach satisfied. If the coach remains upset, the official assumes something must still need to be fixed. But satisfaction and successful communication are not the same thing. Sometimes the correct ruling hurts the coach’s team. Sometimes the answer to his question is not the answer he wants. Sometimes the coach is not looking for information at all. He wants the call changed, the flag picked up, or someone to agree that his team was treated unfairly.
No amount of eloquence can guarantee that he will walk away happy.
A high-performing official understands that some conversations will end without agreement. The official can listen without surrendering his judgment. He can explain without arguing. He can acknowledge the coach’s frustration without accepting the coach’s version of events. Most importantly, he can recognize when he has fulfilled his responsibility, and the only thing keeping him in the conversation is his desire to repair the coach’s opinion of him.
That is often the moment when one more sentence becomes one sentence too many.
Think about the official who has already answered the question but returns to the sideline during the next dead ball to explain it again. Think about the official who follows the coach as the coach turns away because the official has one more point he wants to make. Think about the official who cannot resist correcting the final comment muttered under the coach’s breath.
Why does he do it? Sometimes the answer is ego, but not always in the obvious sense. Ego is not limited to wanting to dominate a conversation or prove that we are smarter than someone else. Ego can also appear as the need to be understood. It can appear as the need to be seen as reasonable. It can appear as the need to make sure the other person knows that our motives were good.
We want to leave the conversation as the hero official—the calm, knowledgeable professional whom the coach ultimately respects and admires. But sometimes there is no heroic ending. Sometimes the coach is going to think you missed the call. Let him.
If you communicated clearly, concisely, and correctly, you have done your job. If new information becomes available, address it. If you discover that you were wrong, own it. If the coach asks a legitimate question, answer it. This is not an excuse to become aloof or dismissive. “I don’t care what anyone thinks of me” is not professionalism. It is often just another form of ego.
The goal is not indifference. The goal is freedom from the need to control the outcome.
That freedom makes officials better communicators. When you no longer need the coach to validate you, you can listen more carefully. You do not have to interrupt because your reputation is not on trial. You do not have to overexplain because silence no longer feels like surrender. You do not have to win the conversation because the conversation was never supposed to have a winner.
You can simply do your job.
Communicate clearly. Communicate concisely. Communicate correctly. Be professional enough to listen, confident enough to answer, humble enough to admit when you are wrong, and disciplined enough to leave when there is nothing more to say.
Then let the coach think whatever he wants. You do not get to control how they perceive you.
Quiz
Read the quiz stem and then choose the best answer. (Choose all that apply.)
3/10 at the A-35. At the snap, the wings throw a flag for an illegal formation. A33 runs around the left end and breaks free. As he approaches the goal line, he turns and backsteps into the end zone while pointing at his opponents.
- Team B will decline the penalty for the illegal formation and accept the penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct
- Both penalties will be enforced; 3/30 at the A-15
- The game clock will start on the snap
- The game clock will start on the referee’s ready for play signal
Review Rules 3-4-3d, 7-2-5 PENALTY, 10-2-4, and 10-4-5a
